Bitcoin’s Battle Over Segwit2x Has Begun


“Download BTC1.” That’s all it took.

Part of a statement in a larger BitPay blog post last week, the words were meant to urge the bitcoin processor’s users to upgrade their software ahead of a scheduled code upgrade. It’s safe to say, however, that they didn’t have the intended effect, setting off a firestorm of angry commentary.

That’s because BitPay was indicating support for “BTC1,” an alternative software client to Bitcoin Core, the one used by over two-thirds of the network. But the blog post didn’t describe the possible consequences of downloading the software. In bitcoin, incompatibility can have economic consequences – namely, the creation of two bitcoin assets, a development that’s still splitting sentiment.

Among the angry voices were notable figures in the blockchain tech community.

Lightning Network creator Tadge Dryja called it “straight up malware,” while Bitcoin Core contributor John Newbery asserted that the post was “dishonest and dangerous.”

The accusation is that the advice was put out willfully by BitPay to confuse users – akin to asking users to say, upgrade their iPhone in a way that would make it so they could no longer message other users, or accidentally sign them up for a new carrier.

As such, the criticisms perhaps had more to say about the state of bitcoin’s technical roadmap and the lingering idealogical battles ongoing among the network’s many different participants.

More broadly, the BTC1 software has emerged as one of the more controversial proposals as it’s based on an agreement made up group of miners, companies and developers, who, claiming that they represent the interests of network users, intend to hard fork bitcoin to increase the network’s block size in November.

And though Segwit2x isn’t scheduled to release the hard fork code for several months, the idea is that doing so could potentially lead to the creation of another bitcoin network, one that would compete with bitcoin and bitcoin cash.

That possibility, it seems, has ripped open old wounds.

Culture of infighting

On social media, no slight is too small if it sends a message.

In another notable incident, a developer for Bitcoin Core went so far as to delist Jeff Garzik, the lead developer for BTC1, from the Bitcoin Core GitHub shortly after the BitPay incident.

Although, that this came to pass perhaps isn’t surprising. For one, Garzik hasn’t contributed to bitcoin since 2014. But the incident does carry a larger symbolism, in that some have labelled Garzik a villain in the ongoing technical battles.

If one of the key charges levied at Segwit2x is that the group, composed of a group of influential bitcoin companies, is trying to “corporatize” bitcoin development, it’s Garzik that has taken most of the heat.

Critics have so far sought to label Garzik a “politician” or else ask (sometimes not politely) that he leave the bitcoin development community entirely. (Garzik was a former employee of BitPay and is now CEO of a startup called Bloq).

Still, Garzik has his defenders, particularly among Segwit2x supporters. Erik Voorhees, whose firm ShapeShift is a signatory, sees the criticisms as reinforcing the idea bitcoin’s development team isn’t open to change.

Users were keen to disagree – and colorfully.

Danger, danger

Yet another touchpoint in the battle has been the idea of security, with each side spending ample time accusing the other of the willingness to put user money at risk for their ideological beliefs.

Chief among these is the budding fight over “replay protection.”

The idea is that if Segwit2x chooses to go through with an attempt to hard fork the block size to 2MB, and the blockchain splits in two, replay attacks could lead some users and companies to lose money. And in the mind of advocates for Bitcoin Core, those backing the new agreement should be the ones to add replay protection.

In this way, the event mirrors developments last summer, when a group of developers began working on ethereum classic, the original blockchain abandoned by a majority of users following a hard fork that proved contentious in its community.

And the concerns have merit, as some users lost funds in the resulting shuffle.

Some developers, who have proved willing to work with the Segwit2x group, have even raised concerns as the BTC1 software has not had replay protection put in place. The charge here is, that’s been done purposefully.

First and foremost, by not doing adding replay protection, the Segwit2x group could avoid the appearance of an impending bitcoin split and encourage more users to adopt its software – and that’s in line with statements from its members, who have argued BTC1 won’t result in the creation of another bitcoin.

Outspoken supporters of a larger block size aren’t being shy that they believe this is the right tactic, predicting Core will be the less-popular chain in the end.

Peace and understanding

Yet, there have been attempts to spur more well-meaning dialogue between the two camps.

Ted Rogers, president of bitcoin wallet firm Xapo (which supports the Segwit2x agreement), argued in a mini tweetstorm that critics often misrepresent what Segwit2x members are trying to accomplish.

“Segwit2x is an honest attempt [at] bringing sides together [with] no split,” he said, before listing a few of the proposal’s benefits.

Rather than argue that Segwit2x is the one true bitcoin, Rogers contends that it will offer the market “a chance to see how different solutions play out.”

The comments build upon what has been a larger drive by BTC1 supporters to frame the proposal as one supported by a free-market design strategy.

Here, the commentary was divided, if less acrimonious.

In response to Rodgers, some bitcoin users responded with a chorus that is likely to only grow louder as November nears, one that stresses the idea that a software upgrade put forward by businesses amounts to a kind of hostile takeover.

Hinting at the heart of the argument, one Twitter user said:

“If a group of CEOs can simply get together and unilaterally change bitcoin, then that means a government could – and hence bitcoin is dead.”

Disclosure: CoinDesk is a subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which helped organize the Segwit2x agreement, and has ownership stakes in BitPay, Bloq, ShapeShift and Xapo.

Correction: An earlier version of this article described Garzik’s removal from GitHub incorrectly. That has been corrected.

What's Your Reaction?

hate hate
0
hate
Angry Angry
0
Angry
confused confused
0
confused
Cute Cute
0
Cute
Fail Fail
0
Fail
fun fun
0
fun
Geeky Geeky
0
Geeky
Lol Lol
0
Lol
Love Love
0
Love
OMG OMG
0
OMG
Win Win
0
Win
WTF WTF
0
WTF

One Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Brucelaw says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Remind yourself to take a break every one in a while and adjust the color temperature of your display to prevent eye strain, with this clever utility

    Press the “Download Now” button to download CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer activate code.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Mirror Link —> CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer crack exe

    – Version: 1.1.22.1
    – Developer: care-eyes
    – Downloads: 1992
    – Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    – File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    – File size: undefined
    – Price: free
    – Special requirements: no
    – Home page: care-eyes.com
    – Rating:

    Tags:
    CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer crack windows
    CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer license crack
    CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer license code
    CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer crack patch
    CareUEyes – Free blue Light Filter, screen dimmer serial key

    Popular software:
    Website 2 APK Builder Pro Full Version Serial Keys Latest
    FoneLab for Android license
    iMyFone iOS System Recovery + Crack Latest
    PrimoCache crack exe
    OBD Auto Doctor Serial Keys x86/x64
    Антиплагиат как пройти бесплатно
    virtual city casino vip
    Convert Google books to PDF, PNG or JPG
    CopyTrans Shelbee Crack

  2. Brucelaw says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download Recovery Toolbox for RAR activate code.
    The process will just take a few seconds.

    Recover important files from unusable and damaged RAR archives, with the assistance of this user-friendly, wizard-based application

    Mirror —> https://downloadcrackfree.com/crack?s=recovery-toolbox-for-rar&id=105628

    · Version: 3.0.0.0
    · Build date: Jun 28th 2018
    · Company: Recovery ToolBox
    · Downloads: 3350
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: small
    · Price: gratis
    · Special requirements: no
    · Supported systems: Win All
    · User rating:

    Tags cloud:
    recovery toolbox for rar licence keys, recovery toolbox for rar crack and keygen free download, recovery toolbox for rar license crack, recovery toolbox for rar update crack, recovery toolbox for rar crack keygen for windows, recovery toolbox for rar serial code, recovery toolbox for rar cracked latest, recovery toolbox for rar license, recovery toolbox for rar keygen serial, recovery toolbox for rar serial code

    More software: this way

    Other useful resources:
    Hello world! | David Laroche Blog
    Антиантиплагиат скачать
    What Is Digital Writing? What Exactly Does It Have To Do With SEO? – Coarq Digital
    Download The Watchmaker (2001) crack hack
    Meet The Dirt Road Degenerates! – POP BLITZ MAGAZINE
    How to Turn Off Windows Defender
    Download SP Flash APK- Guide to Latest Tool Version – SP flash tool download
    ГДЗ, решебники, все ответы с 1 по 11 классы
    Repair missing or corrupt libmysql.dll

  3. Brucelaw says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download cardPresso and crack.
    It will just take a few seconds.

    A complete ID card designing application that comes with an extended set of tools for creating, printing and encoding identification cards

    MIRROR —> https://softwarehomes.in/software/40707/cardpresso-crack

    · Release version: 1.6.40
    · Patch date: July 11 2019
    · Company: cardPresso
    · Downloads: 24644
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: small
    · Price: free
    · Special requirements: no
    · Systems: Windows 10 64 bit, Windows 10, Windows 8 64 bit, Windows 8, Windows 7 64 bit, Windows 7, Windows Vista 64 bit, Windows Vista, Windows XP
    · User rating:

    Tags cloud:
    cardpresso license crack, cardpresso + full crack, cardpresso keygen crack patch, cardpresso key crack, cardpresso + crack latest, cardpresso full patched, cardpresso with crack, cardpresso keygen free download, cardpresso crack only, cardpresso crack

    Popular software: https://softwarehomes.in

    More software:
    About Digital Art | Artodem – Digital Art
    Как повысить уникальность антиплагиат
    Was gitbt’s Neues ? | Deutsch@INSA
    Download Micro Commandos crack install
    Setting Goals for Chattanooga | Old Stude
    download google books free
    Скачать Password Dragon crack и keygen
    Repair missing or corrupt activation64.dll
    MakeMyTrip(MMT) Customer Care – Toll Free Number, Booking/Enquiry

  4. Brucelaw says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download LISCAD serial number.
    The whole process will just take a few seconds.

    An efficient and user-friendly piece of software developed to assist you in compiling land survey data with minimal levels of effort

    Mirror —> LISCAD crack new

    · Version: 2018 (June)
    · Release date: Aug 8th 2018
    · Developer: LISTECH
    · Downloads: 27367
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: no cost
    · Special requirements: no
    · Systems: Windows 10 64 bit, Windows 10, Windows 8 64 bit, Windows 8, Windows 7 64 bit, Windows 7, Windows Vista 64 bit, Windows Vista
    · User rating:

    Tags cloud:
    liscad activator, liscad crack install, liscad how to ctack, liscad crack windows, liscad crack patch, liscad patch, liscad serial key, liscad + full crack, liscad keygen free download, liscad and crack

    More software keygens: https://cracks4software.com

    More software:
    NOW HIRING: TAX CONSULTANT | BRAYN blog
    Антиплагиат повышение оригинальности
    Different operators offering live casino services – Pure Gambling Guide
    Download Hammer & Sickle cracked full
    Top 5 Benefits of Buying Local – Green Business Bureau
    How to Turn Off Windows Defender
    Скачать Hide Trace crack и keygen
    Download nvtoolsext64_1.dll to fix missing or corrupted DLL errors
    India Summer and Emma Hix In Sexy Stiletto Heels – Pornstar Feet

  5. Brucelaw says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Click the “Download Now” button to download [b]Dolby Access crack version[/b].
    The whole process will just take a few seconds.

    [url=https://serialcrack.org/serial/31783/dolby-access.html][img]http://i.imgur.com/aVoIShg.png[/img][/url]

    Take advantage of stunning sound quality and realism in your multimedia experiences, with sound that surrounds you with the help of this app that gives you a free trial of Dolby Atmos.

    Mirror —> [url=https://serialcrack.org/serial/31783/dolby-access.html][b]Dolby Access patch[/b][/url]

    · Version: 3.2.169.0
    · Build date: April 19 2020
    · Company: Dolby Laboratories
    · Downloads: 6318
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · Status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: gratis
    · Special requirements: no requirements
    · Supported systems: Win 10 64 bit / Win 10
    · User rating: [img]http://i.imgur.com/jNp98zs.png[/img]

    [img]https://serialcrack.org/site/images/preview/dolby-access_1.png[/img]

    [b]Tags cloud[/b]:
    dolby access with license key latest, dolby access keygen crack, dolby access crack, dolby access + crack, dolby access keygen serial, dolby access update crack, dolby access serial code, dolby access crack patch, dolby access + full crack, dolby access cracked

    [b]Popular software:[/b] [url=https://serialcrack.org]https://serialcrack.org[/url]

    [b]Popular software:[/b]
    [url=https://crack4download.com/crack?s=Microsoft-Power-BI-Desktop&id=55124]Microsoft Power BI Desktop 2.79.5768.562 / 2.79.5772.0 Store App crack version[/url]
    [url=https://cracks4software.com/cracked/dlnow-14962]DLNow 1.39 Full Version With Keys Latest[/url]
    [url=https://onyxsoftware.in/cracked?app=ntlite&n=95306]NTLite 1.9.0.7428 / 2.0.0.7428 Beta crack files[/url]
    [url=https://flakegames.com/game/734/mechwarrior-4-mercenaries]Download MechWarrior 4: Mercenaries keygen crack patch[/url]
    [url=https://www.sql-server-performance.com/w2k-filesystem-affects-performance/?unapproved=40504&moderation-hash=1287d58b0e58c2f815fb24ab6df96b9b#comment-40504]How Using the Windows 2000 Encrypted File System to Secure SQL Server Databases and Backups Affects SQL Server’s Performance – SQL Server Performance[/url]
    [url=https://freecrackfiledownload.com/software/o-o-diskimage-express-edition/193]Скачать O&O DiskImage Express Edition crack и keygen[/url]
    [url=https://dlls.in/dll/vgcore.dll/24927]How to repair missing or corrupt vgcore.dll[/url]
    [url=https://gamercheatscode.com/patch/the+witcher+3+wild+hunt/24]Download The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt keygen crack patch[/url]

You may also like

Choose A Format
Personality quiz
Series of questions that intends to reveal something about the personality
Trivia quiz
Series of questions with right and wrong answers that intends to check knowledge
Poll
Voting to make decisions or determine opinions
Story
Formatted Text with Embeds and Visuals
List
The Classic Internet Listicles
Countdown
The Classic Internet Countdowns
Open List
Submit your own item and vote up for the best submission
Ranked List
Upvote or downvote to decide the best list item
Meme
Upload your own images to make custom memes
Video
Youtube, Vimeo or Vine Embeds
Audio
Soundcloud or Mixcloud Embeds
Image
Photo or GIF
Gif
GIF format